Awakening His Duchess by Katy Madison

January 26, 2015 Historical, Reviews 4

A brown haired white woman is barely contained in a blue evening dress while the man behind her nuzzles her neckYou guys!! This is the best and worst book ever!! I can’t wait to talk about it in totally spoileriffic detail! Awakening His Duchess is Katy Madison’s update of the traditional I-Was-A-(Spoiler-Alert)-Plantation-Novel!! Can you see me waving my hands around excitedly? It’s gothic! It’s racist! It’s progressive! It’s everything Ronco could make it! Now how much would you pay? But wait!! You also get my review! (Ok, even I am tired of exclamation points. Let’s get to it. You know I love me some Katy Madison) Everything about this book pays homage to 1970’s historicals. It’s like bodice ripper concentrate. Awakening His Duchess starts with a man being buried alive. Like, seriously. Dirt on the face, pounding on the box, the whole bit. We quickly find out he’s the third son of a Duke (because of course!) cruelly betrayed by the girl he’s been lying to but really wanted to marry.

She’s the daughter of a Haitian plantation owner and she’s French. (ZOMG!) Beau is swept off the canvas and  Fleur Yvette is stuck in the midst of revolution. (I’m not sure why I wanted her name to be Fleur through the entire book – the story must remind me of something specific from the earlier era of Haiti-set books.) With blood flowing all around her, she flees to England. England’s fine and all, but it hasn’t any bananas. Until Beau arrives!! (I’m sorry. He doesn’t bring bananas with him. He talks about them endlessly, but he’s just happy to see everyone but Yvette.) Wait, we’re getting ahead of ourselves – let’s head back to the revolution. Spoiler alert – it’s not going well for Yvette’s family.

Slaves who’d cared for her since infancy, who’d fed her, washed her face, sung to her, men and women she’d known her entire life had turned and butchered her family like they meant no more to them than the chickens for supper. – Madison, Katy (2013-01-24). Awakening His Duchess (p. 67). . Kindle Edition.

Now I’m just guessing, but if I had to lay my money down I bet the slaves had a much higher opinion of the chickens than they did Yvette’s family. Madison has it both ways here. Yvette has been a healer to the slaves, against the wishes of her family. She’s seen them whipped and killed. She knows their life expectancy is less than ten years. She’s seen families separated and she’s likely known of rape. Yet she still thinks in terms of loyalty. Yvette is repelled by slavery in England, but she’s fine with the life it gave her on the island.

Her father had been defeated by life in Saint-Domingue. He didn’t understand why he had such a hard time making a profit when other plantations had done well. But he’d met with more than his share of misfortune with his slaves dying off in droves. – Madison, Katy (2013-01-24). Awakening His Duchess (p. 165). . Kindle Edition.

Yea, that really sucked for him. But back to our hero and heroine! When Beau arrives he’s got a pretty wild story for his family. It seems that after digging his way out of the coffin Beau had the misfortune to become a white slave. Yvette heard rumors of such a man existing but assumed that the white slave was an albino. (With race being an artificial construct it’s not like the “white slave” was that unfamiliar to slaveholders. Passing just means moving away from people who know you’re supposed to be black. So the reverse holds true as well – proving you’re actually white would require people who know you are.) Beau blames Yvette for all of his misfortunes. What can keep these crazy kids together? Only a secret baby! Etienne, being a child who lives through a massacre, is not favorably disposed toward Africans. He’s frankly afraid of them. His early conversations with this strange Not-As-Dead-As-Maman-Said-Secret-Daddy tend to go poorly.

“It was a complicated situation. And smarter men than I could debate for centuries about whether it was a good thing or a bad thing. And I was a slave. There was only one side for me to be on. Just as there was only one side for you to be on, but there are no sides here, Etienne.” – Madison, Katy (2013-01-24). Awakening His Duchess (p. 175). . Kindle Edition.

Paternal cop-out on Aisle Beaumont! Etienne is like, well there’s side All-Of-My-Family-Is-Dead, so I think that’s my side. Beau doesn’t want the kid to hate him so he equivocates a lot. I was concerned Madison was going to hit the White Savior drum a little too hard but she keeps it fairly low key. I mean, sure, Etienne owes his life to the slaves figuring out he’s Beau’s kid. Somehow Beau has managed not to smuggle a note out to the island’s government or his family but he has managed to teach his fellow slaves to read and write using the dirt and a stick. (He’s got access to charcoal and banana leaves but whatever, Beau.) There’s the bit where Beau alludes to having played a role in the Revolution. That’s about it.  So we’ve got The Good One and The Healer, placing both of our leads somewhat above the guilt fray. I wanted Madison to go a step farther and acknowledge that the sort of extreme wealth Beau’s father enjoys is based in more than traditional English farming practices, but she pulls back. Take this tea time exchange.

“You like sugar?” she asked, startled. He paused. “Don’t you?” “I don’t use it much since I’ve seen…” Her voice trailed off. He knew better than she what went into harvesting the crop and turning it into the product sent to market. The edges of his lips curled in a self-depreciating smile. “I’d hate to think my labors wasted.” – Madison, Katy (2013-01-24). Awakening His Duchess (p. 260). . Kindle Edition.

I liked this scene in it’s acknowledgement that slavery sustained their lifestyle but I loathed it for Beau’s reasoning. It’s a bit early for Yvette to have planted beets, but she could have become a beekeeper. If she truly objected to the cost of sugar, there were ways beyond refusing it at the table for her to make her feelings known. It’s a little unfair to expect it of her given our modern lifestyles are predicated on a different kind of slavery, but unfair is the reader’s favorite game. (Actually, here’s a little info on sugar farming today, in Florida, and it’s human cost.) Awakening His Duchess was a top read for me until everything came cascading down in the final quarter. While the Evil Guy Behind Everything is totally a staple of the 70’s romance, I’ve lost all taste for it. This particular Big Bad is completely illogical. There are a dozen ways his existence makes little sense. Maybe two dozen. His inclusion was an homage too far. Beau faces his fear, Yvette faces her past, and peril rains down around them. Love wins out and we all wake up safe and snug in our own epilogue. Wait! I totally forgot Mazi! (Don’t worry, for long stretches of the book everyone else forgets him too.) You know Mazi – he’s this guy!

“You may want to stay here.” Beau stopped short of begging Mazi to stay. He already owed his life to the man a dozen times over. “You’ll never want for anything.” – Madison, Katy (2013-01-24). Awakening His Duchess (p. 31). . Kindle Edition.

Mazi is in the book so Beau can be grateful to him. He’s there to prove that the only difference between Beau and a slave who wasn’t third son of a duke (Mazi is considerably higher up the nobility chart) is skin color. Mazi arrives so Etienne can unlearn his racism and come to understand that black faces need not cause terror. In the 70’s we’d either never hear of Mazi again, he’d be a lifelong servant, or he’d bravely die protecting Beau without regret. In this updated version Mazi gets to return home (off camera). He is seriously and completely Beau’s One Black Friend.

Final Assessment: Modern take on the Island To England trope. Hot start, crash & burn finish. A for homage, C for close.

Source: Purchased Copy

The following two tabs change content below.

Meoskop

Meoskop's first non-compulsory book review was in 1973. Although a hit with the 3rd grade, concerns raised by the administration necessitated an extended hiatus. Reviews resumed in 1985 but the concerns are ongoing.

Latest posts by Meoskop (see all)

4 Responses to “Awakening His Duchess by Katy Madison”

  1. Danielle

    Okay, so I thought about commenting, but felt too confused so I closed the browser window. And then I had to open it again, because this book/review is a head-scratcher for me. Probably because the couple of old-school plantation romances I tried creeped me out and I don’t get the nostalgia factor. I remember one I tried was by Jennifer Blake. It was one of the most schizophrenic reads I have had.

    All that to say that this book sounds incredibly – scratch that – sounds all to believably racist and all kinds of twistedly “enlightened” yet it gets A/C? It’s a new book? A is for the successful reproduction of those 1970s plantation romances? And C because the final quarter soured otherwise catchy storytelling?

    I expect there must be more to the book than my brain is grasping. Sorry for the rambling!

  2. Meoskop

    Hey Danielle – I can see why it’s confusing. Some of today’s books are going to seem as bizarre in 30 years as the plantation novels do today. (I’d name some but…).

    The A is for recognizing the racism and othering in those books and trying to address that in this updated one. There’s also some strong characterization and a willingness to get real about the time involved.

    The C is for not fully realizing an update, leaving some problem tropes in place. Also for the Big Bad being so absurdly effective. It failed several logic tests.

    The nostalgia factor comes from my being old – 70’s and 80’s romance was contemporary for me.

  3. Danielle

    Thank you, Meoskop! I’m middle-aged, so those books were available when I grew up – I just didn’t know about them back then.