Everyone loves this book but me. Gwyneth Bolton‘s Rivals in Paradise is a highly rated Enemies-To-Lovers tale that I DNF’d at 22%. Cicely and Chase were college rivals jockeying for social position at the same small school. I’m pretty sure that he’s part of the reason for the terrible day Cicely is having at work when we meet her. After failing to get an expected promotion she walks in on her man cheating in her own bed. Canceling a planned family trip for Thanksgiving, Cicely instead books a flight for the island of Dahinda. It’s apparently tropical, but I’m not familiar with it. (There’s a Dahinda in Ontario and Illinois but they’re snowy.) Chase is on edge after taking a new job (Hmmmmm) that he already regrets. He’s flying home to see family when who should be seated next to him in first class but his long lost nemesis. It was on the plane that Rivals in Paradise shifted from neutral to oh-hell-no.
Chase and Cicely act like high schoolers instead of professional adults. Perhaps it’s my lack of college attendance and failure to join a sorority, but reading about the basis for their anger made me… angry. Is this a real thing? Like, is this set up even possible? Bolton describes a world where historically sibling groups are so alienated on campus that new sorority members are instructed to give the silent treatment to any fraternity member. Ignore them if they speak. Walk around them and don’t make eye contact. Pretend they don’t exist in class. Are they toddlers? Why would you join a group with such requirements? Is this a cultural thing that’s eluding me? How did people keep reading this book????
“As she remembered, she realized Chase had been in one of her classes. She remembered how he would sometimes stand in her way in an effort to make her acknowledge and greet him. She would simply walk around him and not say a word.” – Rivals in Paradise, Gwyneth Bolton
Like, what?? Chase tells Cicely he wants to bury the college hatchet. She agrees, while thinking his back would be the best place for it. Accusations of election fraud and slander fly behind tight smiles and congenial words as both lose themselves in info dumping thoughts Bolton is prone to info dumping via personal reflections. During a phone call with her sister Cicely has multiple musings about the state of Latonya’s marriage. It’s ups, it’s downs, it’s reunions, it’s… take this one.
“Latonya had spent three years away from the family when a misunderstanding caused Carlton to make her leave their home and their child. Latonya had been pregnant with their second child at the time and no one knew it. Those three years made Latonya want to hold her family even closer once she came back.” Rivals in Paradise, Gwyneth Bolton
That’s the third or fourth explanation in three pages. Prior to that we learned Carlton is rich, his grandmother interferes in the marriage, Latonya’s grandmother is beloved, Latonya has Daddy Issues, she doesn’t trust happy endings, etc. The girl just wants her sister to come on the damn holiday trip. We don’t need to know any of this. None of this is relevant. It’s a basket of WTF pretending to be character depth. Rivals in Paradise exceeded my why-is-this-happening meter by a mile. If you’re one of the (many) 5 star reviewers, tell me what I missed because I DNF’d it so hard before Chase and Cicely got off the plane.
Final Assessment: Info dumps war with toddler motivations for these cutthroat professionals. DNF
Source: Library copy